Compare / Portlandia Logistics vs C.H. Robinson
Compare
Portlandia Logistics vs C.H. Robinson
C.H. Robinson is a global 3PL with a huge contract-carrier bench, managed solutions and its own technology platform. Portlandia Logistics is a small Louisville freight desk: published rate math, one named dispatcher, a rate confirmation that locks the accessorials, and an invoice gated on the POD. If you need global forwarding, TMS integration or managed transportation, C.H. Robinson is the right call. If the problem is that the invoice never matches the quote, that is the problem this desk was built around.
They optimize supply chains at scale. We make one shipment behave.
Reviewed November 20, 2026 · Authority and compliance status
Short answer
| Your situation | Better fit |
|---|---|
| Global forwarding, customs, TMS integration or managed transportation | C.H. Robinson |
| You want the rate formula published before you book | Portlandia Logistics |
| A huge national carrier bench, contract capacity and 24/7 coverage | C.H. Robinson |
| One named dispatcher and a direct thread, not an account team and a queue | Portlandia Logistics |
| Accessorials priced and locked in the rate confirmation | Portlandia Logistics |
| Procurement requires a licensed broker or a global 3PL | C.H. Robinson |
Why a shipper leaves a global 3PL for a desk
A 3PL sells program management: many services, one contract, a technology layer over all of it. That is the right purchase for some shippers. It is the wrong purchase when the pain is a single recurring lane whose invoice keeps drifting. This is the structural difference — not a claim about how C.H. Robinson treats any particular customer.
- Program management is priced into the model. Managed transportation, TMS access and consulting are real services, and they are paid for somewhere in the relationship. If all you need is a lane quoted and a load covered, you are buying a larger machine than the job.
- The invoice is where the distance shows up. Linehaul is easy to agree on. Reclass, reweigh, detention, appointment misses and limited-access fees are decided later, by other teams. A desk that prices those lines at booking and locks them in writing removes the most common source of variance.
- Your account is a portfolio entry, not a dispatch board. At 3PL scale the account is managed through a program: routing guides, service targets and a technology stack. The dispatcher covering your load on a Tuesday has not spoken to you before. That is efficient, and it is also why nobody can explain a specific exception without a ticket.
- The rate basis is a trade secret at scale. A global 3PL prices per lane through a rep, a platform or a contract, and the formula is not published. Here the formula is on /rates and the estimate shows the arithmetic it used. You can audit the number before you agree to it.
- Switching is testable. You do not have to migrate a program to test a desk. One lane, one quote, one confirmation, one invoice — and decide from the documents.
This describes the economics of the global-3PL model, not C.H. Robinson’s internal process. Where this page refers to C.H. Robinson scale it repeats figures C.H. Robinson publishes about itself, and asserts nothing about its rates or service levels.
Side by side
| Dimension | Portlandia Logistics | C.H. Robinson |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Freight desk: published rate basis, rate confirmation in writing, POD-gated invoicing | Global 3PL: brokerage, forwarding and managed solutions (C.H. Robinson publishes 450K contract carriers and 37M annual shipments) |
| Coverage | 2,450 published US lane pages across 26 states | Global network plus managed transportation |
| Pricing transparency | Base, mileage, class factor, 18% fuel and fixed accessorial amounts published on /rates | Priced per lane through a rep or platform; the formula is not published |
| Quote flow | Planning estimate in seconds, quote number stored, dispatch notified, firm rate confirmation in writing | Rep, platform or managed program; turnaround depends on lane, volume and contract |
| Carrier verification | MC/USDOT authority and auto liability COI per carrier per load, cargo minimum for general freight, expiry tracked, W-9 and signed agreement before first tender | Broker-managed carrier compliance process |
| Service claims | No on-time percentage, carrier count or rating published, because we cannot evidence one yet | Publishes scale metrics and productivity claims |
| Who you talk to | One named dispatcher, Mon–Fri 8:00am–6:00pm ET; after-hours email for loads in transit | Account team and 24/7 coverage |
| Authority | No brokerage authority claimed; agency home pending | Licensed brokerage authority and global forwarding |
C.H. Robinson figures on this page are from its own public material (450K contract carriers, 75K customers, 37M annual shipments) and are attributed, not adopted. No internal C.H. Robinson metric is asserted, and no claim is made about its rates or service levels.
“Will you save us money?”
We do not know yet, and anyone who quotes you a savings percentage before seeing the lane, the class and the handling is guessing. What we publish instead is the arithmetic behind the number, the accessorial amounts, and the rate confirmation that locks them. Compare the invoice, not the pitch.
What we put in writing
A comparison is only as good as the parts of it you can hold someone to. These are the parts this desk commits to before the freight moves.
- Published quote math. The estimate shows the basis it used: base, mileage, class factor, fuel and every accessorial amount. The same table is on /rates. Read the rate basis
- One named dispatcher. One person owns the load from quote to proof of delivery — no account-team handoff, no ticket queue, no rotating rep. How dispatch works
- The rate confirmation. Lane, carrier, pickup window, handling lines and the final rate in writing before pickup. The estimate is a planning range; the confirmation is the contract. What a confirmation should name
- Accessorials priced before pickup. Liftgate, residential/limited access, appointment, inside delivery, hazmat, temperature and rigging are quoted at the fixed published amounts above, not discovered at delivery. Insurance and value-added handling
- An invoice gated on POD. The invoice follows the signed delivery record and the confirmation lines. Claims open against the carrier cargo policy, and the desk documents the file. How claims work
What the number is built from
The published planning basis the quote form uses. Mileage is ZIP-geocoded with a 1.17 road factor, so exact addresses can move the final rate; the firm rate appears on the rate confirmation.
| Mode | Published planning formula |
|---|---|
| LTL | $145 base + $0.62 per planning road mile + $0.045 per lb + $18 per pallet, then the NMFC class density factor |
| Truckload (dry van) | $2.35 per planning road mile, $575 minimum, weight adjustment above 20,000 lb |
| Flatbed | $2.85 per planning road mile, $575 minimum, weight adjustment above 20,000 lb |
| Intermodal | $185 base + $0.52 per planning road mile, plus weight and pallet handling |
| Drayage | $325 base + $1.45 per planning road mile (port and rail terminal moves) |
| Fuel | 18% of the linehaul on LTL, truckload, flatbed and intermodal; no fuel line on drayage |
Fixed accessorial amounts — added only when declared:
- Liftgate at pickup/delivery — $95
- Residential / limited access — $110
- Appointment window — $45
- Inside delivery — $65
- Hazmat handling — $150
- Temperature controlled — $125
- Flatbed / rigging — $175
What we honestly do not have
A comparison page that only lists wins is not a comparison. These are the limits of this desk today — read them before you read the rest.
- Broker authority today. No brokerage authority is claimed. Brokerage freight moves through a licensed agency home once that agreement is active. Contract-for-hire carrier authority under USDOT 7728111 is separate and is not brokerage authority.
- A carrier app or load board. There is no driver app, no self-serve load board and no carrier marketplace. Loads are offered by the desk to carriers whose authority and certificate of insurance are on file.
- A 24/7 phone desk. Mon–Fri 8:00am–6:00pm ET. After hours, email the lane and pickup window: the on-call dispatcher answers for loads already in transit, and new quotes are answered the next business day.
- Global forwarding or customs. Domestic US freight only. No ocean or air forwarding, no customs entry, no NVOCC or FMC forwarder authority.
- EDI, a native TMS connector or a booking API. The quote API and the public rate index are live. There is no EDI, no prebuilt TMS connector and no booking or tender API — booking happens by the desk.
- Numbers we cannot evidence. No on-time percentage, no savings claim against any named competitor, no customer count and no rating. If a number is not published with its basis, treat it as absent.
Where C.H. Robinson is the right call
- You ship internationally or need customs, forwarding or a global network.
- You need EDI or API integration into an existing TMS, or a managed transportation program.
- Procurement requires a licensed broker with a national carrier bench.
- Your volume requires contract capacity and 24/7 coverage that a small desk cannot guarantee.
- You need supply-chain analytics across thousands of shipments, not one load.
Where Portlandia Logistics is the right call
- The invoice is the problem: you want accessorials priced and locked before pickup, not added after delivery.
- You want to see why the number is what it is: base, mileage, class factor, fuel and accessorials are published.
- You want one named dispatcher who owns the load from rate confirmation to POD, with a direct email thread.
- The freight is palletized, crated or high-value equipment where liftgate, appointment, residential/jobsite and stackability details decide the outcome.
- You are moving LTL or partial freight where reclass, reweigh and detention are where the margin disappears.
Where the big-broker invoice goes wrong, and what we put in writing
- **Accessorials** — liftgate, residential, appointment, inside delivery, hazmat and temperature are quoted at fixed published amounts and locked on the rate confirmation. Anything added later needs your agreement.
- **Reclass and reweigh** — if the commodity is ambiguous, the class assumption is stated on the quote and dispatch verifies dimensions and packaging before the rate is confirmed.
- **Detention and appointment misses** — free time and the appointment window are named on the rate confirmation; wait time is documented on the BOL, not folded into a later invoice.
- **POD disputes** — the invoice is issued only after the signed delivery receipt is on file, and the invoice matches the confirmation line for line.
- **Claims** — opened against the carrier cargo policy, documented by the dispatcher who owned the load, with any gap above the carrier limit stated on the rate confirmation before tender.
Questions
Why would a shipper leave C.H. Robinson for a small desk?
Rarely because the 3PL failed at scale. The usual trigger is a recurring lane where the invoice keeps differing from the quote, and nobody can explain the difference without a ticket. A desk that publishes the basis, locks the accessorials and puts one person on the load is a way to test that on one lane.
Can Portlandia Logistics beat C.H. Robinson on price?
Not always. C.H. Robinson buys capacity at a scale a small desk cannot match, and on high-volume contract lanes it will often be cheaper. We compete on the number you actually pay: published rate math, locked accessorials, a named dispatcher and an invoice gated on the POD.
Do you hold broker authority like C.H. Robinson?
Not today. C.H. Robinson is the licensed counterparty in this comparison. No brokerage authority claimed; agency home pending. Freight is arranged through Dynamic Distribution Solutions LLC dba Portlandia Logistics. No tenders are accepted while the agency home is pending, and if your procurement requires a licensed property broker to hold the contract today, C.H. Robinson or another licensed broker is the correct counterparty.
Do you handle international freight?
No. We move domestic US freight: LTL, full truckload, intermodal and drayage. For ocean, air or customs, use C.H. Robinson or another forwarder or customs broker.
How is the rate built?
Base, planning road miles, weight, pallets, an NMFC class factor and an 18% fuel surcharge, with accessorials at the fixed published amounts. The full basis is on /rates and the estimate shows the formula it used.
Who owns the load?
One named dispatcher from rate confirmation to delivery, Mon–Fri 8:00am–6:00pm ET, with after-hours email for loads already in transit. No account-team handoff and no queue.
Read the primary sources
Everything this page claims about this desk is published elsewhere on the site: the rate basis, authority and compliance, carrier insurance requirements, the claims process and the quote API.
Proof of authority
Dynamic Distribution Solutions LLC dba Portlandia Logistics · operating authority application in progress. Authority status →
Start here
Get the estimate, see the basis, then decide
No card is charged from the quote form, and no account is needed to see a number. The estimate is a planning range; the rate confirmation is the contract.
Get an instant quote Read the rate basis Services and scope Browse lanes